CHALLENGE PRODUCTS
Our Challenge Products! The Hottest of the Hot! Enjoy!
For All Old Agness Store Challenge Products:
Please refrigerate upon arrival.
Store in refrigerator until you are ready to be Challenged!
Bring to room temperature before you attempt!
Good Luck!
Free Shipping on all orders of $50.00 or more in the USA!
To Order Old Agness Store Challenge Products in the UK and Europe, please go to
For Canadian Orders
email Old Agness Store directly!
Old Agness Store Challenge Products are baked on
Thursday & Fridays and
Shipped on Mondays and Tuesdays!
THE TOFFEE HUT - HEART OF FIRE CHALLENGE!
AN OLD AGNESS STORE EXCLUSIVE!From THE TOFFEE HUT Toffee Company of the United Kingdom, THE HEART OF..
$15.00 $17.00
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE CHILI CHERRY NIGHTMARE
Welcome to Johnny Scoville’s Chili Cherry Nightmare!!Do you have what it takes to finish t..
$23.50
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE CHILI CHERRY NIGHTMARE - WHITE CHOCOLATE
Welcome to Johnny Scoville’s Chili Cherry Nightmare!!Do you have what it takes to finish t..
$23.50
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE KRAZY KIMBERLIN BAR
Krazy Kimberlin’s Bar has returned temporarily, while supplies last ** Welcome to the Krazy Kimberl..
$22.50
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE MOAB
M.O.A.B... (Mother Of All Bars)Welcome to the 1 bar challenge. Do you have what it takes to fin..
$18.50
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE MOAB GOLD
M.O.A.B...GOLD(Mother Of All Bars)Welcome to the 1 bar challenge. Do you have what it takes to finis..
$18.50
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE NEMESIS
NEMESIS 4x Hotter than the MOAB.This bar starts with our delicious dark chocolate. Next we add ..
$29.50
WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE RASPBERRRRY RAIN
RASPBERRRRY RAIN Raspberrrry Rain starts with our delicious dark chocolate infused with Carolin..
$25.50