SWEETS & SWEET HEATS

FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $35.00 OR MORE IN THE USA!

HEAT has permeated our SWEETS! Weighing between 4 to 8oz each, depending on variety, our Luscious selection of Big, Bold and Beautiful Brownies will satisfy the chocolate lover in your life! Choose a Heat Level of your choice from Traditional (No Heat) to Chili Head Reserve XXX ( HOT!) for a very Special Delight! 


  • Our Baked Goods are made with Gluten Free Ingredients and are created with Guittard Chocolate, one of the finest chocolate in the world based in San Francisco, CA, USA
  • Our heat of choice is sourced from Puckerbutt Pepper Company grown from their own USDA Organic Farm.
  • Our Baking Days are Thursday and Friday and our Shipping Days are on the following Monday and Tuesdays via Priority Mail.
  • Free Shipping on Combined Brownie, Blondie and Bar Orders of $35.00 or more in the USA!
  • For Canadian Orders, please email Old Agness Store! 


GIFT #9 The Berlant Box!

GIFT #9 The Berlant Box!

The finest of the finest of the Old Agness Store®️ Collection! We choose for you with your pref..

$150.00

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  BLACK OPS

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE BLACK OPS

Here it is!! This bar will not disappoint! Black Ops is dark chocolate with Black Rifle Coffee Murde..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  CALL FOR BACKUP BAR

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE CALL FOR BACKUP BAR

This is a bar for everyone! Call For Backup is made with our creamy and smooth Milk Chocolate. $1.00..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  CHILI CHERRY NIGHTMARE

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE CHILI CHERRY NIGHTMARE

Welcome to Johnny Scoville’s Chili Cherry Nightmare!!Do you have what it takes to finish t..

$21.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  CLAYMORE BAR

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE CLAYMORE BAR

A Chocolate Bar with a kick AND A POP!!! Claymore is milk chocolate with AJi Lemon Drop P..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  COUCH POGTATO

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE COUCH POGTATO

If you’re not a fan of spicy, this is the bar for you! Presenting Willy Pete’s Couch Pogtato Chocola..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  FIRE PIG BAR

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE FIRE PIG BAR

Who doesn’t love BACON?!  Try our milk chocolate infused with our home grown dehydrated Ca..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  FRAG OUT

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE FRAG OUT

Love a chocolate bar with a crunch?  If so, you’ll enjoy Frag Out ~ milk chocolate infused with..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  KRAZY KIMBERLIN BAR

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE KRAZY KIMBERLIN BAR

Krazy Kimberlin’s Bar has returned temporarily, while supplies last ** Welcome to the Krazy Kimberl..

$19.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  MOAB

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE MOAB

M.O.A.B... (Mother Of All Bars)Welcome to the 1 bar challenge. Do you have what it takes to fin..

$18.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  NEMESIS

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE NEMESIS

NEMESIS 4x Hotter than the MOAB.This bar starts with our delicious dark chocolate. Next we add ..

$32.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE  ‘MERICA

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE ‘MERICA

The patriotic ‘MERICA bar from Willy Pete’s Chocolate, has home-grown fruit on good ol’ American soi..

$6.50

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE SHRAPNEL CHOCOLATE BAR

WILLY PETE’S CHOCOLATE SHRAPNEL CHOCOLATE BAR

Shrapnel is rated MILD on the Scoville Scale and BIG in flavor! Dark chocolate infused with home gro..

$6.50

Showing 46 to 58 of 58 (4 Pages)